[Study]The Most Dangerous Intersections in Ohio
Posted in Car Accident on July 23, 2020
Intersection related motor vehicle crashes are a leading cause of injury and death in Ohio. In fact, from 2014-2019, nearly half of all collisions that resulted in injury or death occurred at an intersection.
Where are the most dangerous intersections in Ohio? We collaborated with data visualization agency 1Point21 Interactive to find out.
We analyzed six years of collision data from the Ohio Department of Transportation, isolating only crashes where an injury or fatality was reported. The result is a comprehensive analysis of 438,553 total crashes that occurred from 2014-2019, leading to 49,819 serious injuries, 249,570 minor or moderate injuries, and 6,453 fatalities.
We then calculated a danger index, a score that weighs the volume of crashes, injury severity and fatalities that occurred at each intersection. Then, we ranked each intersection by the danger index score.
(This analysis also included over 325,000 possible injuries. We decided not to use these in our danger index formula since the severity and veracity of each injury is unknown)
This interactive map shows all intersections in Ohio with a Danger Index score of 40 or above. This map is interactive – use your mouse to click and drag and mouse wheel or gesture to zoom in and out. Hover over each point on the map to reveal detailed information for that intersection. If viewing study on a mobile device, rotate your device for the best viewing experience.
The 50 Most Dangerous Intersections in Ohio
The following are the top 50 most dangerous intersections in Ohio. Altogether, these 50 intersections accounted for 2,201 total crashes, leading to 1,775 total injuries (both serious and minor) and 13 fatalities.
|Rank||Intersection||City||Crashes||Minor Injury||Serious Injury||Fatality||Danger Index|
|1||Cleveland Av & Morse Rd||Columbus||71||52||3||2||188.64|
|2||OH 28 & Romar Dr||Miami TWP||53||39||17||0||183.6|
|3||Hamilton Rd & Livingston Ave||Columbus||66||49||6||0||174.96|
|4||Airport Hw & Byrne Rd||Toledo||78||36||9||0||166.32|
|5||Karl Rd & Morse Rd||Columbus||56||55||2||0||166.32|
|6||Hilliard Rome Rd & Renner Rd||Columbus||51||42||7||1||159.84|
|7||Cleveland Av & Dublin Granville Rd||Columbus||66||45||3||0||155.52|
|8||James H Mcgee Bl & 3Rd St||Dayton||50||32||13||0||151.92|
|9||Roberts Rd & Hilliard Rome Rd||Columbus||46||38||9||0||147.6|
|10||Main St & Mcnaughten Rd||Columbus||65||43||2||0||146.88|
|11||Philadelphia Dr & Salem Ave||Dayton||45||46||4||0||146.16|
|12||Broad St & Reynoldsburg New Albany Rd||Columbus||51||35||8||0||141.12|
|13||Cleveland East Liverpool Rd & Cleveland Canton Rd||Streetsboro||45||34||9||0||138.24|
|14||Byrne Rd & Hill Ave||Toledo||46||28||7||2||133.2|
|15||OH-601 And US-20||Townsend Township||20||25||13||2||129.6|
|16||Cleveland Av & Hudson St||Columbus||45||38||3||0||125.28|
|17||Sylvania Av & Whiteford Rd||Sylvania Township||53||30||6||0||124.56|
|18||Orange Av & 30Th St||Cleveland||89||28||0||0||124.56|
|19||Turner Rd & Main Street||Harrison Township||57||24||6||1||121.68|
|20||Dublin Granville Rd & Maple Canyon Ave||Columbus||49||35||3||0||121.68|
|21||Morse Rd & Westerville Rd||Columbus||48||26||7||0||115.92|
|22||Georgesville Rd & Clime Rd||Columbus||36||26||9||0||114.48|
|23||James Rd & Broad St||Columbus||54||30||3||0||114.48|
|24||Morse Rd & Sunbury Rd||Columbus||42||33||1||0||105.12|
|25||Sullivant Av & Binns Blvd||Columbus||30||30||5||0||104.4|
|26||Byrne Rd & Arlington Ave||Toledo||48||22||6||0||103.68|
|27||Walnut ST & Tarlton Rd||Circleville Township||18||23||9||1||102.24|
|28||Grand Av & Breiel Blvd||Middletown||42||30||2||0||102.24|
|29||Germantown St & Broadway St||Dayton||35||30||1||1||100.8|
|30||Airport Hw & Reynolds Rd||Toledo||55||20||5||0||100.8|
|31||Jackson Pike & Frank-Refugee Exp||Columbus||30||30||4||0||100.8|
|32||Dublin Granville Rd & Busch Blvd||Columbus||28||25||7||0||99.36|
|33||Gettysburg Av & James H Mcgee Blvd||Dayton||43||26||3||0||97.92|
|34||Cleveland Av & Oakland Park Ave||Columbus||38||31||1||0||97.92|
|35||Morse Rd & Tamarack Blvd||Columbus||36||26||2||1||96.48|
|36||Roosevelt Bl & Breiel Blvd||Middletown||40||28||2||0||96.48|
|37||Holland Sylvania Rd||Toledo||52||24||2||0||96.48|
|38||Oh-603 & Us-20||Mifflin Township||24||23||8||0||95.76|
|39||Liberty Wa & Cox Rd||West Chester Township||24||19||8||1||94.32|
|40||Woodman Dr & Burkhardt Rd||Riverside||39||24||4||0||94.32|
|41||Karl Rd & Dublin Granville Rd||Columbus||45||25||2||0||93.6|
|42||Columbus Sandusky Rd & Marion Cardington Rd||Claridon Township||18||16||12||0||90.72|
|43||Colonel Glenn Hw & Grange Hall Rd||Beavercreek||33||21||6||0||90.72|
|44||Feder Rd & Hilliard Rome Rd||Columbus||35||27||2||0||90.72|
|45||James H Mcgee Bl & Philadelphia Dr||Dayton||32||21||4||1||90|
|46||Refugee Rd & Courtright Rd||Columbus||33||19||7||0||90|
|47||Main St & Progress Dr||Xenia||22||26||5||0||90|
|48||Powell Rd & Columbus Pike||Orange Township||40||25||2||0||90|
|49||Broad St & Mcnaughten Rd||Columbus||48||24||1||0||90|
|50||Stelzer Rd & Mccutcheon Rd||Columbus||31||31||0||0||89.28|
As part of this study, we also broke down the 25 most dangerous intersections in each of the six largest cities in Ohio.
These cities are:
The Most Dangerous Intersection in Ohio is in Columbus
According to our analysis, the most dangerous intersection in Ohio is in Columbus, on the corner of Cleveland Avenue & Morse Road. Columbus in general dominates our list of dangerous intersections – 24 of the top 50 are located in Ohio’s most populous state.
This intersection in particular was home to 71 total crashes, leading to 52 minor injuries, 3 serious injuries, and 2 fatalities. At the southeast corner of the Forest Park East neighborhood, this intersection is the joining of two of the busiest major arterial roads in northeast Columbus. Arterial roads are those with wide lanes, high traffic, and speed limits that are more suited for highways than city streets – all major contributors to decreased road safety.
Morse Road is a major east-west connector road, with 6 lanes of traffic and major businesses and shopping centers along its route. The constant stop-and-go of traffic, combined with vehicles entering and exiting these shopping centers, can be a major contributor to the high incidence of crashes here.
Additionally, it is important to note that this intersection has an intricate layout when traveling westbound on Morse, with lanes widening and then shrinking to fit whatever lanes necessary to turn onto Cleveland Avenue. Three lanes widen suddenly to 6 for turning lanes, only to shrink immediately back to three lanes after passing Cleveland. This, combined with an incredibly large intersection area, may disorient newer drivers – as well as those who may be driving while distracted.
Other safety measures should be considered at this intersection. Perhaps even more distinct lane signage and marking may contribute significantly to reducing collisions at this intersection.
Other Notable Intersections
#2: OH 28 & Romar Dr. – Miami Township, OH (53 total crashes, 39 minor injuries, 17 serious injuries, 0 fatalities)
East of Cincinnati, the intersection of OH-28 and Romar Drive in Miami Township ranked second in our analysis primarily due to the concerningly high number of serious injuries that have resulted at this intersection. Of the 50 intersections in our study, this had the highest number of serious injuries by far, with the next highest being 13.
This is an especially alarming statistic, considering the circumstances: Miami Township is fairly small, even by Ohio city standards, with a population of roughly 41,000 residents. By comparison, Columbus has nearly 20 times the population.
The high incidence of collisions leading to serious injuries here may be due to a number of factors:
- This is an intersection of a major state roadway and the business route of that roadway. Business routes typically get much higher traffic in the form of large trucks and load-carrying vehicles, which are inherently more dangerous in accidents than standard automobiles.
- There are multiple shopping centers at this corner, including a mall and a major home improvement store.
- This intersection is located right off a major highway, Interstate 275. Roads which are exit outputs for high-traffic freeways typically have a higher incidence of car accidents, due to the speeds at which people exit highways and the number of drivers that surge onto the major road.
Further, as mentioned previously, this is another example of a major arterial road with potentially confusing road flow and large intersections – a recipe for dangerous car accidents in those that are not paying full attention to the road.
UPDATE: It appears that safety improvements may be on the way for this intersection and the roads around it. June 30th, 2020, ODOT closed a virtual public meeting about the project. No results were available at the time of this study.
#5: Airport Hwy & Byrne Rd – Toledo, OH (78 total crashes, 36 minor injuries, 9 serious injuries, 0 fatalities)
Ranked fifth, this intersection in Toledo was home to 78 total crashes, leading to 36 minor injuries and 9 serious injuries. Despite being an intersection in the fourth-most populous city in Ohio, this particular location had an incredibly high number of total crashes – more collisions than the most dangerous intersection on our list, and second only to a Cleveland intersection ranked 18th.
At first glance, there is not much that may explain the high incidence of crashes: although Airport Hwy is a state roadway, it is fairly narrow, with two lanes on each side – and a manageable 40mph speed limit. Additionally, this is a quiet, predominantly residential area of Toledo, so there is not much high traffic.
However, this high incidence might be due to its close vicinity to The University of Toledo Medical Center, connected to this intersection by Byrne Road. This may contribute not only to the high volume of traffic, along with drivers who are traveling with urgency to the hospital for immediate medical care. Speeding and not paying full attention can be especially dangerous in residential areas with narrow lanes, where speeds can suddenly pick up and slow down erratically.
Interestingly, the intersection two blocks north of this one, on Byrne Road and Hill Avenue, is also on our list, ranked 14th. This may indicate that Byrne Road in general may have a high amount of traffic contributing to a higher incidence of collisions.
#15: OH-601 & US-20 – Townsend Township, OH (20 total crashes, 25 minor injuries, 13 serious injuries, 2 fatalities)
This intersection in Townsend Township may be ranked 15th, but it is arguably a more concerning intersection that some that are ranked higher. This is one of the few intersections in our analysis where the total number of injuries is significantly higher than the total number of crashes. When the total injuries and fatalities are tallied, it is double that of the total crashes – indicating that each single crash results in roughly 2 injuries.
This is all the more concerning when population is taken into consideration: Townsend Township is a rural community with a population of just over 1,500 residents. By comparison, the 8th ranked intersection in Dayton has the same number of serious injuries – despite having a population that is 100 times larger than that of Townsend Township.
Two factors may explain this intersection: the rural setting and the lack of signals. Rural settings invite drivers to bend the rules of driving a bit more, taking fewer safety precautions as there are fewer people around. This can include speeding, not wearing a seatbelt, not using proper turn signals, etc. Compounding with the fact that both US-20 and OH-601 are single-lane roads in each direction, this can be a recipe for disaster.
Additionally, this intersection is not governed by signal lights, but rather a two-way stop sign at OH-601. Any attempts to turn from OH-601 to US-20 can be incredibly dangerous – especially if vehicles are speeding along and not prepared for vehicles to turn into the highway.
Drivers are always advised to practice safe driving – even in rural communities where there are few cars on the road.
#18: Orange Avenue & 30th Street – Cleveland, OH (89 total crashes, 28 minor injuries, 0 serious injuries, 0 fatalities)
Although the only intersection located in Cleveland on this list is ranked 18th, it also happens to have the most total collisions of any other intersection in our analysis. Looking at its location, it is clear why: the intersection is an entire mishmash of roads connecting, redirecting, and diverting highway traffic to other roads, highways, and interstates. It is reasonable to assume that a significant amount of traffic passes through this intersection, as drivers make transitions from one highway to another – a task which can be incredibly difficult under high traffic situations.
This may serve to explain the high incidence of crashes but zero serious injuries: many of the collisions here may occur in low-speed, high-traffic situations, amounting to fender-benders where bumps and scrapes are the result.
Unfortunately, short of a major rehauling of the highway junction system here, there do not seem to be any easy changes to improve safety.
Distracted Driving is Likely a Huge Factor – But That May Change
When considering the possible causes for these high incidences of accidents, Ohio authorities believe that distracted driving is the primary contributing factor to serious car accidents in the state. According to the Ohio State Highway Patrol, over 91,000 car accidents since 2013 have occurred due to distracted driving – leading to over 47,000 injuries and 305 fatalities.
Part of the reason why distracted driving has been such a large factor in car accidents in Ohio is that the state has categorized it as a secondary offense. Law enforcement is not allowed to pull over vehicles due to secondary offenses; these are can only be charged if you are pulled over for a separate infraction. This means that drivers who may have been engaged in distracted driving have not been caught by the police because they are otherwise practicing “safe” driving.
Fortunately, in February 2020, the state has introduced the Hands-Free Ohio Bill, which aims to make distracted driving a primary offense. Although the bill is still currently under legislation, it can hopefully curb the influx of serious car accidents and aim to reduce the total number of distracted drivers on the road.
It remains to be seen whether further improvements can be made to ensure the safety of drivers in Ohio, but studies like these will hopefully inform enough people to empower change and improvement in driver safety across the board.
For more information on the methodology, data sources or takeaways of the study please contact us.